Thoughts as new year begins
My Spectrum column, the general technology column that I write for the Toronto Star, listed today what I believe will be the defining technology trends in 2006. Among them I mentioned that cleantech investments will continue to soar, building on the back of multibillion-dollar commitments in 2005 from the likes of General Electric, Ford, British Petroleum and others. I’m also seeing more entrepreneurs and investors, who made their fortunes (or lost them) during the high-tech boom, now turning their attention to alternative energy and other cleantech ventures, either in executive roles or in an angel/VC capacity.
Examples including Greg Kiessling, who sold his Toronto software company a few years ago for $52 million and has since used his wealth to back the creation of renewable energy retailer Bullfrog Power. His private venture capital firm, Up Capital, appears to invest exclusively in clean energy startups.
There’s also Mac Brown, former chairman and majority owner of now defunct Linux software company Rebel.com, which fell into receivership four years ago. Brown has resurfaced on the Ottawa scene as president of Magenn Power Inc., which has developed a blimp-like generator for the wind power market. Even veterans, such as MacDonald Dettwiler founder John MacDonald, have moved on to cleantech. MacDonald is now CEO and co-founder of a solar technology venture in Vancouver called Day4 Energy.
These Canadians join a list of U.S. tech-turned-energy gurus that include Idealab founder Bill Gross, who is focused on solar technology; Desh Deshpande, founder of Sycamore Networks Inc., who is now chairman and investor in lithium-ion battery innovator A123Systems Inc.; and venture capital heavyweight Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, which has become one of the leading venture capital investors in cleantech companies and is blazing a trail for other tech generalists in the VC community.
Of course, the pitfall to all of this is that hype overshadows reality — as it did during the dot-com boom and bust. The rising interest in cleantech is real, but as the sector becomes more popular it risks being diluted by wild promises and unrealistic claims. I’m already beginning to see this as I look for new companies to profile on this blog. Separating the good from the bad is becoming increasingly difficult, and already some VCs are dismissing the term “cleantech,” saying it will quickly become outdated and overused — or already has.
On the other hand, key drivers — i.e. rising oil, natural gas and gasoline prices; supportive government policy and legislation; widespread public support and increased awareness; commitments from major market players; Kyoto and global warming concerns; and rising business costs — are all very real. This, perhaps, makes it even more necessary than ever to challenge and scrutinize the business plans and claims of emerging players in the cleantech field as they jump to exploit a problem-filled world in need of solutions.

Tyler Hamilton is editor-in-chief of Corporate Knights magazine and a business columnist for the Toronto Star, Canada's largest daily newspaper. In addition to this Clean Break blog, Tyler writes a weekly column of the same name that discusses trends, happenings and innovators in the clean technology and green energy market. This blog is a personal project started in April 2005. It is not an official blog of the newspaper.